Video courtesy of: North Carolina State University Libraries http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/tutorials/peerreview/
When you are determining whether or not the article your found is a peer-reviewed article, you should consider the following questions:
Is the journal in which you found the article published or sponsored by a professional scholarly society, professional association, or university academic department? Does it describe itself as a peer-reviewed publication? (To know that, check the journal's website).
Did you find a citation for it in one of the databases that includes scholarly publications? (Criminal Justice Abstracts, EBSCOhost Academic Search Complete, PsycINFO, etc.)? Read the database description to see if it includes scholarly publications.
Did you limit your search to scholarly or peer-reviewed publications?
Is there an abstract (summary) at the beginning of the article?
Is the tone of the article thoughtful, restrained and serious?
Does the article have footnotes or citations of other sources?
Does the article have a bibliography or list of references at the end?
Are the author's credentials listed?
Is the topic of the article narrowly focused and explored in depth?
Is the article based on either original research or authorities in the field (as opposed to personal opinion)?
Is the article written for readers with some prior knowledge of the subject?
If your field is social or natural science, is the article divided into sections with headings such as those listed below?
|
|
From the Librarians at Lloyd Sealy Library at John Jay College
Everyday, we use information from some place to answer our questions. Where is my friend's new house? Where is the cheapest gas? Is it healthy for my pet to eat bubblegum all day? What is the relationship between the rising costs in the housing market and job growth in my town?
Depending on the type of answer you are looking for, or the type of research you are doing; the places you go to find information can be very different from one another. All research involves asking a question. So, before you ask your question, you should think about why you are asking it, and where you want your answer to come from.
If you are looking for the cheapest gas, then using an app on your phone, or looking it up through Google will most likely get you the answer quickly and accurately.
However, if you are assigned a research project for your class that asks you to explore the rates of housing costs and their relationship to employment opportunities, then the research process just got a little bit more complicated. Here's where this tutorial comes in. This guide will walk you through what scholarly information is, where to look for it, how to identify it, and best practices for using it in your academic research projects.
Deciding on a starting place to find scholarly information for your research project can be tough. There are a lot of options out there, in terms of types of sources (newspapers, books, magazine, journals, T.V.) and access points (library database and websites). Here are a couple things to consider before diving into the giant ocean of information that is out there.
We've all heard the word before; credible. But what does credible mean to us, as an academic researcher? To complicate matters, you'll also hear other terminology that goes along with credible. Words like, scholarly, peer-reviewed, academic, and authoritative can be confusing when used without context; but good news, all these words describe the same type of information. So it's important to remember that all the above could be used interchangeably by your teacher, or someone who you are doing research for/with.
So, now we know people use different words to describe information that is appropriate for use in academic research, and that is great; but now the question is, how do we know what it looks like when we try to find it? Here's a checklist that you can use when determining the credibility of a document/piece of information.
Five Criteria for Evaluating Information |
|
Evaluation of documents |
How to interpret the basics |
1. Accuracy of Documents
|
Accuracy
|
2. Authority of Documents
|
Authority
|
3. Objectivity of Documents
|
Objectivity
|
4. Currency of Documents
|
Currency
|
5. Coverage of Documents
|
Coverage
|
Putting it All Together
You may have a higher quality document that could be of value to your research! |